Large files were much faster than the small-file workload. SSDs gave little benefit for this single-user file-copy case.
Test setup, measurements & limitations
AS5404T — ITPro original review
Tested: Four 1TB HDDs in RAID 5 and two 1TB NVMe SSDs in separate RAID 1, synchronized before testing; storage loaned by Western Digital, exact drive models not disclosed. Single 2.5GbE link; Windows 11 laptop for copies. Also tested a two-HDD 12TB RAID 1 array and SSD caching.
Applies to: Exact enclosure model; conclusions apply to the stated tested storage and network setup.
- Large files were much faster than the small-file workload. SSDs gave little benefit for this single-user file-copy case.Source location: Testing / performance / setup section
- The reviewer saw little change when testing the SSD volume or a two-HDD 12TB RAID1 array, and no advantage from SSD caching in this case. These observations do not compare database or multi-user workloads.Source location: Performance, alternate configurations
- HD playback remained smooth while a Handbrake transcode ran in Docker at nearly full CPU usage alongside a large copy. Codec, stream count and transcode throughput were not disclosed.Source location: Performance, Plex and Handbrake paragraph
Measurements reported by the reviewer| Measurement | Result | Conditions & source location |
|---|
| 2MB block read / write | 281 / 256 MB/s | ATTOPerformance section; associated test paragraph or chart |
|---|
| Single multi-gigabyte file transfer | 283 MB/s | Copies to and from Windows 11 laptop; article reports maintained 283 MB/s without separate direction values.Performance section; associated test paragraph or chart |
|---|
| Small-file average transfer | 71 MB/s | 11,000 files; reported average across reads/writesPerformance section; associated test paragraph or chart |
|---|
| ATTO 4KB read/write | nearly 48 / 45 MB/s | Single 2.5GbE link; benchmark described after synchronized HDD RAID5 and SSD RAID1 setup; exact ATTO version/queue depth not stated.Performance, ATTO paragraph |
|---|
| ATTO 16KB read/write | 164 / 167 MB/s | Same ATTO setupPerformance, ATTO paragraph |
|---|
Limits to keep in mind
- Do not infer that SSDs never help databases or concurrent users.
- One review sample is not long-term failure-rate evidence.
- Exact drive models, ATTO version and queue depth, and client CPU/storage model are not stated.
- The storage was loaned by Western Digital; this does not establish the chassis sample arrangement.
- No independent acoustic, power or thermal measurements are given.