One self-bought ST16000NT001 was reported as clicking and undetected. The description says the same behavior on multiple SATA and power connections; the Sabrent dock is how the clip was filmed. SeaTools on camera shows only a Samsung SSD. This is one owner story from 2023, not a failure rate.
Test setup, measurements & limitations
New Seagate IronWolf Pro 16TB (ST16000NT001) Drive beeping and clicking error DOA
Tested: Self-bought Amazon mid-February 2023, titled ST16000NT001. Description: same non-detection on multiple SATA/power connectors; Sabrent DS-UTC1 dock used in the video for simplicity, not as the only tried path. Windows Disk Management and SeaTools on camera list a Samsung SSD 860 EVO 1TB, not a 16TB Seagate.
Applies to: Single-owner 2023 non-detection/click report of a drive the author identifies as ST16000NT001. Not a failure-rate study and not a current Seagate replacement-policy document.
- The owner reports the drive was not detected, with beep/click sounds, and that the same behavior occurred on multiple power connectors and SATA cables. The dock is how the video was filmed, not the only connection tried.Source location: Expanded description; ASR 0:24–1:25
- The paused ~0:32 frame shows SeaTools/Disk Management listing only the Samsung SSD 860 EVO 1TB. Parent did not listen to the soundtrack to verify clicks.Source location: Parent frame 0:30/0:32
- Seagate lab/30-day/refurb comments are the owner’s 2023 account, not verified current warranty policy. The owner also says two 4TB IronWolf disks had run five years in FreeNAS and that Rescue previously recovered another enterprise drive — anecdotes, not fleet statistics.Source location: Expanded description
Limits to keep in mind
- One sample. Not a diagnosed root cause. Audio not independently heard.
- Selected frame plus full 0:00–1:31 ASR, not complete audiovisual viewing.